How to use digital twins in pharma to enhance your supply chain

Managing Consultant, Decision Design, NNE

Leif Poulsen

Managing Consultant, Decision Design, NNE

Leif Poulsen is an expert in business analysis and conceptual design of automation and IT solutions, including how to deploy such solutions effectively in a GxP regulated environment. As a subject matter expert within automation and IT, his focus is on manufacturing execution systems (MES), advanced automation and IT solutions and how they can support current and future business objectives. 

Leif Poulsen is member of the ISA SP88 Batch Control CommitteeISA SP95 Enterprise/Control Integration Committee and a member of the GAMP Forum. In 2011, Leif Poulsen was awarded the ISA ‘Excellence in Documentation Award’ for his article on deployment of MES in the pharmaceutical industry. In 2013, he was certified as a TOGAF Enterprise Architect.

When talking about digitalization in the industry, we often hear the phrase "digital twin". But what is a digital twin and what can it be used for? In this TechTalk article, Leif Poulsen gets to grip with this question and offers some examples of how this technology is used in the pharmaceutical industry.

A digital twin is a digital model of a physical object in the supply chain. This model is a "mirror image" of a physical object, where functions and properties are represented by digital information.

Within pharma manufacturing, we tend to work with digitally modelling the following physical objects:

  • The production building
  • The production process
  • The product itself
  • The patient

Fig. 1: Digitalization in 4 areas of the business supply chain

 

These are often referred to as the 4-P model, or “digital quadruplets” (detailed above). Digital models of these objects can be used to design and optimize individual physical objects and, if combined, to design and optimize the entire supply chain. So what are the possibilities for digitalization, design and optimization in these 4-P areas?

Digitalization of production buildings

For many years, advanced 3D tools for modelling geometric properties have supported the design of buildings and building elements. Indeed, it is now possible to create very realistic visualizations of a building's interior and even let people take a virtual walk around before it is physically built. This is particularly effective for sales.

However a 3D model can also be used for many other things. For example, it can help to ensure there is space for any necessary production and supply systems, and during a project, a 3D model is often used by project managers to match deliveries from different suppliers.

 A 3D model can also have features for modelling the building's more dynamic properties – such as modelling the amount of energy consumed under varying production and weather conditions (see fig. 2).

Fig. 2 Simulation of energy flow in building

Digitalization of the production process

Physical experiments are often used to optimize processes, but you can also use digital models to find better solutions. These digital models are often based on mathematical or stochastic models (or a combination of the two), and are gradually integrated into the geometric modelling techniques mentioned above.

A good example of this is optimizing the process of mixing different granules for tablet production. MIT in the United States has developed an advanced mathematical model of a continuous process, where it is possible to estimate how effective a mixing plant is at homogenizing granules as a function of its physical design. This can be visualized using different colours for single particles in the granulate (see fig. 3).

Fig. 3 Simulation of granulate flow in mixer. Source: CD-adapco

Digitalization of the product

Physical experiments are used to design and optimize the product itself. However digital models are increasingly being used in, for example, the design and optimization of medical delivery systems, such as insulin pens. New pens are usually designed from a digital platform, and then a large part of the design is reused in many different pen variants.

With the help of digital models, it is possible to quickly examine whether a new variant fits into the existing production equipment or not (an example of design for manufacturing). In addition, many types of newer pens also have electronic functions that can, for example, tell a patient how to use the pen correctly, and also send information about a treatment program to a doctor or hospital (see fig. 4).

Fig. 4 Digitalization of products (InPen). Source: Companion Medical

Digitalization of the patient (the customer)

Products across all industries are increasingly manufactured to suit customer needs. This also applies in the pharmaceutical industry, where products are now adapted for smaller patient groups and ultimately the individual patient  - also known as personalized medicine. Therefore, it is increasingly important to have a digital model of a patient's medical information so they get the right products and the most effective treatment.

A good example of this is cell therapy, where patients are treated with modified cells from their own body. In these cases it is crucial that digital information taken from analyzing individual patients is channelled efficiently and safely to production equipment. This then produces the personalized drug for the patient – for example, based on the results of a gene analysis (see fig. 5).

Fig. 5 Personalized drugs may be based on analysis of genes

Dynamically optimize your supply chain

Pharma manufacturing has been slow to adopt integrated digitalization compared to other industries. Within car and aircraft manufacturing, for example, integrated models are already used to optimize processes and products according to customer needs.

However there are clearly many benefits of integrating the 4 models briefly described above. By embracing this technology, it is possible to dynamically optimize the entire supply chain - so products are optimized for patient needs, the production process is optimized for products manufactured and the production building is optimized for production processes.